Even though we have only read the
first four books of the Odyssey so far, it has already become evident that
hospitality will be a recurring theme throughout this epic poem. Hospitality is
obviously very important in the ancient Greek culture, and it is vastly
different than what most of us consider as hospitality today. According to
Homer’s Odyssey, proper hospitality in ancient Greek culture involves treating a
stranger to the best food and drink one can offer, and perhaps even providing a
nice bath before asking the stranger who he or she is. This type of hospitality
was so foreign to me that I had trouble believing that this was the norm. However,
this is in fact one of the most basic rules of this society, and all of the
respectable characters in The Odyssey
treat their guests this way without hesitation.
But why did
the Greeks have these rules for hospitality? What is the reason behind automatically
treating total strangers as guests of honor? I believe one reason for this
culture is due to the common Greek belief that gods and goddesses often
disguise themselves as strangers. Knowing that any random stranger could be a
god in disguise naturally motivates hosts to treat every guest as a god, no
matter what the situation may be. Homer’s story reinforces this idea, as
Telemachus treats Athena disguised as Mentes hospitably in the opening book. Despite
the fact that Telemachus is already suffering from a plague of parasitic
suitors, he genuinely welcomes Athena into his house. The text reads: “[…] and
straight to the porch he went, mortified that a guest might still be standing
at the doors. […] ‘Greetings, stranger! Here in our house you’ll find a royal
welcome. Have supper first, then tell us what you need.’(1.140-141, 144-146)” Considering
his situation, the fact that Telemachus is “mortified” that he might have
forgotten about a guest really emphasizes how important hospitality is to him. This
scene in itself teaches Homer’s audience that hosts should always be aware that
strangers may be gods in disguise.
Another
reason why the ancient Greeks had this custom of generosity towards strangers is
because they either expected to be treated this way in the future as strangers
themselves, or they had already been treated this way in the past by other
hosts. In The Odyssey, both Nestor
and Menelaus had been received hospitably by other hosts during their journey
back from Troy, and this in turn played a role in influencing them to be
hospitable towards Telemachus. In the case of Menelaus, he specifically
mentions how he enjoyed hospitality from other men during his voyage home: “Just
think of all the hospitality we
enjoyed at the hands of other men before we made it home […]. (4.38-39)” To
Menelaus, it is absurd to receive hospitality and not do the same in return.
This reveals the general mindset and belief of Greeks to treat others the way
you wish to be treated, and to give as you have received.
I believe
that in The Odyssey, hospitality can
be used as a dividing line to separate the morally upright from the evil. All of
the characters that have shown hospitality so far (Telemachus, Nestor, and
Menelaus) are considered “good guys”. However, we view the characters that have
broken the rules of hospitality in a bad light. For example, the suitors are
clearly villains at this point, and they have abused the hospitality of
Penelope and Telemachus as guests. Another example of a villain is Calypso, and
she is being a terrible host by holding Odysseus captive on her island.
Although this may not be a cause-and-effect relationship, there seems to be a
correlation between showing hospitality and having good character. Overall,
hospitality seems to be a bigger theme in this poem than one might expect.
Works
Cited
Homer. The Odyssey. Translated by Robert Fagles, Penguin,
1996.
I think these are some excellent points miewow. Hospitality does seem to be a good way of judging characters however I think calypso is somewhat of an exception as a goddess that also does help to send Odysseus home with gifts and warns him of the path ahead. However, I also wonder if perhaps these Greek ideals have something to do with our society's "treat people how you want to be treated" way of thinking.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Camron in that in that Calypso doesn't exactly belong in the "bad guys" category. While she does force Odysseus to stay on her island, she also welcomes him and is the perfect hostess. In addition (I know you haven't actually read book 5), but Calypso is actually the perfect hostess to Hermes when he comes bearing bad news to her that she has to let Odysseus go. She gets all the food out, and gives Hermes time to rest before asking him about why he is there. I really liked your point about how you didn't expect hospitality to be such a big theme, because it surprised me how much it was brought up and projected onto so many different people.
ReplyDeleteI also think these are some great points. One interesting thing is the guests don't really worry about intrusion, until the most recent books we have been reading where Telemachus thinks he may have overstayed his welcome. Another concern is that the guests show up completely unannounced. In modern society, by a wide stretch of the imagination, I could see someone being this thoroughly hospitable, but to a guest they were expecting, and maybe even--I don't know--invited!
ReplyDelete